An argument against chinas one child policy

According to a proclamation of the International Conference on Human Rights, "Parents have a basic human right to determine freely and responsibly the number and the spacing of their children.

Some scholars claim that this decline is similar to that observed in other places that had no one-child restrictions, such as Thailand as well as Indian states of Kerala and Tamil Nadu, a claim designed to support the argument that China's fertility might have fallen to such levels anyway without draconian fertility restrictions [2] [73] [5] [74].

According to the article local officials were being pressured into purchasing portable ultrasound devices to identify abortion candidates in remote villages. Paul Schultz of Yale University discussed the effect of the transformation to the market on Chinese fertility, arguing that the introduction of the contract responsibility system in agriculture during the early s weakened family planning controls during that period.

Hong Kong is exempt from the one-child policy and the Hong Kong passport, which is different from a China mainland passport, provides additional advantages.

I say, let a human right be partially suppressed for a limited time in order to avoid the very real and severe consequences of a over-populated nation.

Since the s, some people have worried that this will result in a higher tendency toward poor social communication and cooperation skills among the new generation, as they An argument against chinas one child policy no siblings at home.

The program was intended to be applied universally, although exceptions were made—e. Beginning in earlyall families would be allowed to have two children. On the other hand, foreigners who frankly have no adequate knowledge about any of these problems, who are only propelled by their ideals, have no right to make any judgement on this issue.

What are the arguments FOR the one child policy in china?

Human rights violation and forced abortions: What we need to do is change our attitudes, not have more children. Well, if fertility increased to replacement level of 2. Recently though, the Hong Kong government has drastically reduced the quota of births set for non-local women in public hospitals.

Although it is an old policy, it continues to be a very controversial topic even to this day. It was implemented more effectively in urban environmentswhere much of the population consisted of small nuclear families who were more willing to comply with the policy, than in rural areas, with their traditional agrarian extended families that resisted the one-child restriction.

The program was intended to be applied universally, although exceptions were made—e.

One-child policy

It had risen from This policy is well constructed with fairness and justice in mind: Solid population growth in China is a good thing. Also prominent voices joined in the criticism. There are alternative means. If a couple already has two or more boys, the sex ratio of higher parity births swings decidedly in a feminine direction.

Any kind of one-child policy will be unattractive, but the alternative looks to be worse. Countries that simply improved access to contraceptives—Thailand and Indonesia, for instance—did as much to reduce fertility as China, with its draconian policies. Traditionally, male children especially firstborn have been preferred—particularly in rural areas—as sons inherit the family name and property and are responsible for the care of elderly parents.

Debate: China

Ethnic minorities who have their own unique ways of life and unique cultures are not forced to accept a policy that the majority ethnic group has established. The article also reported that women as far along as 8.

Although couples in China are only allowed to have one child, there are many exemptions to this policy to make it as fair as possible. In demand grew for making the limit one child per family. Sarah Conly is an associate professor of philosophy at Bowdoin College.

Since the s, some people have worried that this will result in a higher tendency toward poor social communication and cooperation skills among the new generation, as they have no siblings at home.

Maybe technological fixes will save us, ending our unsustainable depletion of natural resources and our contributions to climate change. No one thinks that if a religion required, say, human sacrifice, those who follow it would be allowed to engage in ritual killing, no matter how sincere their belief.

China estimates that it has three to four hundred million fewer people today with the one child policy than it would have had otherwise. We know that in the past the fertility rate has been sensitive to finances, with fewer births in both the Great Depression and following the recession, so financial reward seems an effective mechanism.

One-child policy in China: An economic system based on growth, where growth means more people using more resources, will eventually face a crisis.One-child policy, official program initiated in the late s and early ’80s by the central government of China, the purpose of which was to limit the great majority of family units in the country to one child each.

"One child" policy helps fight against global warming "China Says One-Child Policy Helps Protect Climate". Reuters. 30 August Reuters. 30 August In solving the pollution and the environment, China advocates this policy in helping reduce their carbon dioxide output. The one-child rule has been estimated to have reduced population growth in the country of nearly billion (estimated, ) by as much as million people over its first 20 fmgm2018.comr the male-to-female ratio eases with the discontinuation of the one-child policy will come clear over time.

Apr 18,  · Individual rights argument: It takes freedom of choice away from parents to decide the kind of family they want. Economic argument: The sharp decline in birth rate resulting from the one child policy means there will be too few workers to support their social security system in the Resolved.

China's one-child policy was part of a birth planning program designed to control the size of its population. Distinct from the family planning policies of most other countries (which focus on providing contraceptive options to help women have the number of children they want), it set a limit on the number of children parents could have, the world's most extreme example of population planning.

the one child policy in China is right

Objective (Req.): Students will analyze China’s one -child policy, determine the pros and cons and then take part in a structured debate about whether or not they believe it was an effective.

An argument against chinas one child policy
Rated 0/5 based on 71 review